Uber, taxi competition and public transport financing: MOLO calls for fair competition rules
The mobility market is changing, but the rules of the game, from the perspective of the transport associations, are not keeping pace everywhere. In particular, the increasing influence of digital matchmaking platforms such as Uber is occupying the local taxi and rental-car sector. At the same time, private bus companies are struggling with rising costs and an uncertain financing of public transport (ÖPNV). These topics were the focus of discussions in mid-November between the transport associations VDV Rheinland and VVRP and representatives of the Rhineland-Palatinate Chambers of Industry and Commerce (IHKs) in Ludwigshafen. The managing directors Guido Borning (VDV Rheinland) and Heiko Nagel (VVRP) use the long-established dialogue to assess current developments in the transport sector and to develop joint positions on political and economic framework conditions.
Uber and other platforms: Competition needs oversight
Participants discussed in particular the growing influence of digital brokerage services on the taxi and rental-car market. With providers like Uber, local competition is changing. For the transport associations, it's not fundamentally about whether digital business models belong in the market. What is decisive is whether the same legal requirements apply to all providers and whether these are enforced. The focus was on the obligations of taxi and chauffeured transport, in particular the return-to-base requirement, the verification of licensing prerequisites, and the role of the competent authorities. Municipal minimum transport fares were also discussed. They can help limit distortions in competition between taxi and rental-car offerings.
“We have fundamentally nothing against digital brokerage models or new offerings. What is decisive, however, is that fair competitive conditions apply to all market participants. The legal requirements must not only exist on paper, but must be implemented and enforced consistently by the competent authorities,” explains Heiko Nagel, managing director of the VVRP.
Thus the associations focus their attention mainly on municipal supervision. Because legal requirements only have effect when licensing authorities also use their control options.
Private bus companies under cost pressure
Besides the taxi and hire-car market, the financing of public transport was a topic of discussion for the participants. Private bus companies face rising personnel and operating costs. At the same time, many public authorities are financially under pressure. For the transport companies, it becomes more difficult to plan reliably in the long term. Therefore, the associations are calling for transport contracts that take into account the actual cost development. An important role here is played by price escalation mechanisms, with which rising personnel, energy and operating costs can be reflected during the contract term.
The increasing municipalization of bus transport was also the subject of critical discussion. From the associations' perspective, private companies must be adequately considered in the organization and awarding of public transport services. They deliver a substantial portion of the transport services and require reliable economic conditions for that.
"We need a capable public transport system, but it must also be organized and financed in a financially sustainable way. The private bus companies make an indispensable contribution here. What matters are fair competitive conditions, adequate contracts and financing that the companies can rely on in the long term," emphasizes Guido Borning, Managing Director of VDV Rheinland.
Local Public Transport Plan: Between Ambition and Affordability
Also the further development of public transport in Rhineland-Palatinate and the state public transport plan were on the agenda. The central question: How can an attractive transport offering be reconciled with the limited financial resources of the state and municipalities? The associations advocate aligning policy expansion goals more closely with the actual financial and operational possibilities. A transport-policy desired offering must also be practically implementable and sustainably financed. Otherwise, ambitious plans risk failing due to economic realities.
Driver Shortage: Making It Easier to Enter the Profession
Another problem links taxi and bus industries: the shortage of qualified driving personnel. In bus transport, according to the associations, the high costs and bureaucratic requirements mainly hinder entry into the profession. As a possible solution, Borning and Nagel see closer integration of driver's license training and professional driver qualification. The “two-in-one” principle could reduce training times and costs. Additionally, the associations advocated for a broader offering of foreign-language examinations.
“We must make access to the driving profession easier, faster and cheaper. The merging of driver's license training and professional driver qualification would be an important step,” Borning and Nagel emphasized.
Pooling Common Interests
The exchange between transport associations and IHKs is to continue in the future as well. The advocacy is organized via MOLO – Mobility & Logistics Rhineland-Palatinate e.V. The umbrella association bundles the interests of VDV Rheinland and the VVRP Rheinhessen-Pfalz. Together the two member associations represent, according to their own statements, around 1,400 companies in the areas of freight transport, furniture transport, bus transport, as well as taxi and rental-car transport.
“Whether taxi and rental-car transport or public transport: We are facing significant changes. All the more important is that we regularly exchange views, address developments early, and keep the interests of our companies in view together,” the SME representatives concluded.
For the taxi industry, one question remains open: whether the demand for fair competitive conditions against platform providers will also lead to more stringent everyday oversight. Because regular exchange between associations and chambers is a start. What will be decisive is whether the discussed positions also translate into concrete measures by the competent authorities.
Content automatically translated.
Taxi-Fahrzeuge (Pkw) , Taxi-Newsletter, Taxameter, Taxi-Fahrer , BZP – Deutscher Taxi- und Mietwagenverband , Straßenverkehrsordnung (StVO) , Krankenbeförderung , Weiterbildung , Taxi-Konzessionen , Verkehrspolitik , Mietwagenbranche , Taxi-Apps , Berufskraftfahrer-Qualifikations-Gesetz BKrFQG) , Taxizentralen , Personal, Gehälter, Arbeitsschutz , Wirtschaftsnachrichten , Werbung , Taxi-Folierung , Taxi-Umrüster , Straßenverkehr , Elektromobilität, Taxifuhrpark und -flottenmanagement , Taxi-Versicherungen , Hybrid, Diesel, Erdgas , Taxi-Magazin