2 Ausgaben kostenlos für Sie
Fachmagazin taxi heute: Ihr Zugang zu exklusiven Inhalten rund um die Taxi- und Mietwagenbranche.
Aktueller Termin
Meist gelesen
Robotaxi Debate: Tesla’s Series of Accidents in Austin and the Lessons for Germany
The vehicles, all of them automated Model Y vehicles, are still operating in limited numbers—around a dozen cars are currently on public roads. Even so, the incidents were enough to reignite the debate over safety and transparency.
The accidents were reported as required to the U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). The basis is the so-called Standing General Order 2021-01, which requires manufacturers to report, within five days, any incident in which driver-assistance systems or autonomous controls were active. While other providers such as Waymo submit detailed reports, Tesla remains conspicuously tight-lipped. Many details in the documents are redacted, and narrative descriptions are entirely absent. That makes it hardly possible to infer whether and how the autonomous system played a role.
Particularly sensitive: Tesla continued to rely on safety drivers in the robotaxis, who sit in the driver’s seat and are supposed to intervene in an emergency. Nevertheless, collisions occurred.
Videos prove traffic violations
The NHTSA had already opened investigations before the crashes. They were triggered by videos on social media showing Tesla’s robotaxis flouting traffic laws. In one case, a vehicle stopped in the middle of the road for no apparent reason. Another reportedly hesitated while turning and then steered across a double line into oncoming traffic. Speeding violations were also documented: instead of the permitted 48 km/h, the vehicles at times traveled at around 56 km/h.
The agency then requested comprehensive data, including video recordings and telemetry. Tesla did provide them, but insisted they were confidential trade secrets that may not be made public.
Comparison with Germany
In Germany, such a procedure in this form would hardly be conceivable. Since the Autonomous Driving Act came into force in 2021, strict rules have applied: Vehicles may operate without a driver only in designated operational areas. In addition, a technical supervisor must be able to intervene at any time. For approval, the Federal Highway Research Institute (BASt) requires extensive safety evidence and continuous data collection. Even after an incident, detailed information must be forwarded to the competent authorities, including driving data, sensor data, and a precise error log.
How strictly these rules are applied is illustrated by an example from Hamburg: autonomous shuttles have been operating there since 2023. The vehicles are under continuous technical monitoring and submit comprehensive data to the authorities for every incident. Only after several test phases with onboard safety operators did they receive approval for regular operations.
While Tesla argues in the United States that its own data are trade secrets, in Germany it is clearly stipulated that safety interests take precedence over commercial confidentiality. Companies must demonstrate that their systems ensure road safety—otherwise they risk losing their operating permit.
Thus, in Austin it remains unclear what exactly happened—and whether Tesla’s robotaxis are truly ready for everyday deployment. Pressure on U.S. authorities is likely to grow to harmonize transparency standards. A look at Hamburg shows: Without binding disclosure obligations, trust in autonomous mobility is unlikely to emerge.
Content automatically translated.
Taxi-Fahrzeuge (Pkw) , Taxi-Newsletter, Taxameter, Taxi-Fahrer , BZP – Deutscher Taxi- und Mietwagenverband , Straßenverkehrsordnung (StVO) , Krankenbeförderung , Weiterbildung , Taxi-Konzessionen , Verkehrspolitik , Mietwagenbranche , Taxi-Apps , Berufskraftfahrer-Qualifikations-Gesetz BKrFQG) , Taxizentralen , Personal, Gehälter, Arbeitsschutz , Wirtschaftsnachrichten , Werbung , Taxi-Folierung , Taxi-Umrüster , Straßenverkehr , Elektromobilität, Taxifuhrpark und -flottenmanagement , Taxi-Versicherungen , Hybrid, Diesel, Erdgas , Taxi-Magazin
